We Watched Every 2026 Christmas Ad So You Don't Have To — and Only One Actually Earns Its Tears
Photo by Photo by Igor Sporynin on Unsplash on Unsplash
It is 20 November 2026, and the Christmas adverts have been with us since roughly Bonfire Night. Every year they arrive earlier, like a relative who insists on helping with the washing-up and somehow makes it worse. This year, we watched all the big UK contenders in one sitting, with a notepad, a cup of tea and a growing sense of dread. Here is the only ranking that matters.
How we scored them
We kept it simple. Three categories, ten points each.
Emotional Manipulation — Did it make us feel something, or did it merely press the weepy button marked 'piano'? Celebrity Cameo — Was the famous face a lovely surprise or a distraction from the fact that nothing happens for three minutes? Product Recall — Could we remember what the shop actually sells by the end credits?
A perfect score is 30. Nobody got 30. One came close.
The try-hards
John Lewis — 'The Understudy'
A scruffy dog trains to take over a school nativity after the original star gets stage fright. It is beautifully shot, the dog is excellent, and the whole thing is engineered to make you cry into a mince pie. Emotional manipulation: 9. Celebrity cameo: 1 (a national treasure in a hat, blink and you miss her). Product recall: 2. You leave thinking about the dog, not the sofa. Total: 12/30.
Sainsbury's — 'The Big Shop Musical'
A supermarket aisle breaks into song, led by a pop star whose name you will forget by January and a chef who looks faintly embarrassed to be there. It is loud, colourful and exhausting. Emotional manipulation: 6. Celebrity cameo: 9. Product recall: 7. Total: 22/30. It is not bad. It is just a lot.
Marks & Spencer — 'This Is Not Just a Christmas Advert'
A cinematic universe of famous people eating prawns in slow motion. It is basically a fashion show with a side of gravy. Emotional manipulation: 4. Celebrity cameo: 10. Product recall: 8. Total: 22/30. You remember the coats. You remember the food. You do not remember a single human emotion.
The ones that almost worked
Amazon — 'The Lonely Robot'
A small robot waits by a window for a parcel that never comes, then gets a hug. It is sweet, quiet and genuinely well made. Emotional manipulation: 8. Celebrity cameo: 0. Product recall: 4. Total: 12/30. The problem is you could swap the logo for any tech brand and nobody would notice.
Aldi — 'Kevin and the Sprout'
Kevin the Carrot returns, this time mentoring a nervous sprout through its first Christmas. It is silly, self-aware and mercifully short. Emotional manipulation: 4. Celebrity cameo: 1. Product recall: 9. Total: 14/30. A reliable little workhorse of an ad.
Boots — 'You're Worth It'
Real families, real bathrooms, a nurse with a very good coat. No celebrities, no snow, no choir. Emotional manipulation: 7. Celebrity cameo: 0. Product recall: 8. Total: 15/30. It is the advert equivalent of a warm bath. Nobody will tweet about it, but nobody will hate it either.
The winner
Tesco — 'The Kitchen Table'
Ninety seconds. One family. No celebrities. An argument about sprouts. A grandmother's empty chair. A bag for life on the counter. That is it. That is the ad.
It works because it does not beg. The tear comes from recognition, not from a piano being lowered into frame. You know it is Tesco because of the Clubcard and the slightly chaotic kitchen. You remember what they sell because the whole thing happens around a shop.
Emotional manipulation: 9. Celebrity cameo: 0. Product recall: 9. Total: 18/30. It is not the flashiest ad of 2026. It is the only one that trusts its audience.
Has the tearjerker finally jumped the shark?
Yes. Mostly.
The annual Christmas ad has become a genre with its own rules: a sad child, a misunderstood animal, a cover version of a song you used to like, a final shot of a logo. When you can predict the emotional beat from the first frame, you are not being moved. You are being managed.
John Lewis and Sainsbury's are not bad adverts. They are over-engineered ones. They have mistaken length for depth and celebrity for warmth. The tearjerker jumped the shark the moment retailers started releasing behind-the-scenes documentaries about their own adverts. We are now three layers deep in irony.
But the winner proves restraint still works. A kitchen table, a family, a bag for life. No choir. No snow. No famous face explaining the true meaning of Christmas. Just a shop reminding you that it exists, and a room reminding you that you have one.
That is the 2026 verdict. Tesco wins. The try-hards can keep their pianos.